Index » Beatmaps » Map Requests » Horie Yui - True truly love

either ar10 or ar9 diff I think would fit in ranked as it was made in 2013
2016 can stay loved idm

https://osu.ppy.sh/beatmapsets/97595#osu/260838

will go for ar9 diff then, cuz its the one without the added ar10 text in diff name

bubble :p

I disagree with this being moved up to ranked, I feel like this map does a poor job of representing the music and is more focused on being an aim and flow map for fun. That's what loved is for and I think this fits that criteria far better than ranked.

Digitalfear117 wrote:

I disagree with this being moved up to ranked, I feel like this map does a poor job of representing the music and is more focused on being an aim and flow map for fun. That's what loved is for and I think this fits that criteria far better than ranked.

wasnt thinking this would be much of an issue as stuff like this https://osu.titanic.sh/b/779075 is ranked as well and I dont see this being much different

Umbre wrote:

wasnt thinking this would be much of an issue as stuff like this https://osu.titanic.sh/b/779075 is ranked as well and I dont see this being much different

This was ranked well before I joined Titanic, and I am not one to go back and change maps that were previously ranked. If given the choice today I would not rank this. I want to remind you that this isn't a veto, I am just explaining that I don't want to nominate this for rank.

Looking at the map you linked, it has some very odd difficulty distribution.

Here you can see around 24 seconds the map is at it's most difficult, which doesn't make sense considering this isn't the most intense part of the song. The most intense parts are at the kiai around 58 seconds. Also why aren't the other chorus parts marked as kiais? Like around 01:44:036? This map isn't really complete, it could use some smoothing out and some mods to get it to a point where I would want to rank it. My issues don't have to do with it being too hard, it's just a matter of where is it hard.

The issue of course is this is a very old map, the original mapper is unlikely to want to come back and update it even on bancho. And that's okay, maps like this one (and Truly truly love) are still enjoyable and deserve a leaderboard, I just don't feel they deserve to be awarded the status of ranked.

fair enough